Report warns of jury service 'trauma'

First study of its kind highlights whether people called for jury service should be screened


A new report by psychologists at the University of Leicester warns of the dangers of jurors facing trauma because of their exposure to harrowing and gruesome evidence.  In the first study of its kind, the research highlights how women jurors are more vulnerable, particularly if the trial covers material that resonates with their personal histories.

The research confirms that jury service, particularly for crimes against people, can cause significant anxiety, and for a vulnerable minority it can lead to severe clinical levels of stress or the symptoms of post traumatic stress disorder.

The study led by clinical psychologist Dr Noelle Robertson has been published in The Howard Journal. It warns of the perils of undergoing jury service- and the fact that people cannot talk about their experiences for fear of being held in contempt of court.  Dr Robertson, with University of Leicester colleagues Professor Emeritus Graham Davies and graduate student Alice Nettleingham, is the first UK exploratory study to look at the possible traumatisation of jurors.

The report claims jury service can be a significant stressor for a vulnerable minority and goes on to debate whether screening might be employed to eliminate jurors from potentially traumatising trials.  Dr Robertson said: “Recent research on post-traumatic stress disorder has revealed that it is not only victims of violence or crime that suffer trauma, but that those who interact with them may also be affected.   “If called to jury service, citizens of Britain, as well as the US and most Commonwealth countries, are obliged to serve and may be exposed to gruesome exhibits and harrowing stories, which, the study shows, can lead to traumatisation for some of them.”

An average of 390,000 British citizens serve on juries each year and, after no other preparation than a film outlining their duties, may be exposed to the distress of witnesses or required to handle repellant exhibits and examine graphic and shocking photographs.  When they retire to reach their verdict they have to discuss and weigh up the evidence and may be under pressure to change their own views or to try and change the views of others.   All this can lead to short-term or long-term distress.  The times during trials when jurors were required to make decisions were cited as the most stressful, but having to deal with evidence that might be horrific was also a source of concern, particularly for women, who were also more adversely affected by dissension and questioning in the jury room.

While Dr Robertson urges caution in the interpretation of what was a small-scale Leicester study, it does bear out research from North America, and confirms that jury service can be a source of stress, which for some people can be overwhelming.  The report recommends more support for jurors, including more comprehensive preparation, briefing and clear directions, as well as guidelines for the decision process in the jury room.   It also recommends that Crown Courts could provide a supporter for jurors, who might lessen the sense of isolation jurors can feel, since they are unable to discuss the court case outside the jury room.

Currently, people called for jury service are allocated by lot to juries, and the report also calls for use of a questionnaire highlighting past experiences which would save jurors from the trauma of cases that might resonate with their own past experiences.

Dr Robertson commented: “Jury service is a civic duty, yet we know little about its consequences for the individual. At present, anyone who talks openly about their experiences runs the risk of being charged with contempt of court.”

  • Robertson, N., Davies, G. M. & Nettleingham, A. (2009). Vicarious traumatisation as a consequence of jury service. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 48, 1-12 

For more information on this please contact Dr Noelle Robertson,  email nr6@le.ac.uk.

Share this page:

Funds to support research

Funding opportunities.

The School has limited funds to support research at several levels:

Forms

Ethical approval application

Research review proforma

Upcoming Events
Understanding Stress Workshop Sep 28, 2021
Interviewing Skills Training (online taught) Sep 29, 2021
Manage your Team Collaboration Space Sep 29, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 4: The Performance Development Discussion Meeting Sep 30, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Oct 04, 2021
Part 1 - Team Collaboration Space - Channels and conversations Oct 05, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 1: Introduction to Performance Development Discussions Oct 06, 2021
Funded qualifications to consider for your PDD Oct 06, 2021
Effective Contract Management Oct 08, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 1: Introduction to Performance Development Discussions Oct 12, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 2: Preparing for PDDs Oct 14, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 3: Setting Effective Priorities (objectives) Oct 14, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 1: Introduction to Performance Development Discussions Oct 18, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 4: The Performance Development Discussion Meeting Oct 18, 2021
Part 2 - Team Collaboration Space - Collaborate on documents Oct 19, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Oct 20, 2021
Understanding Stress Workshop Oct 25, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 1: Introduction to Performance Development Discussions Oct 25, 2021
Recruiting at The University of Leicester (online taught) Oct 26, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 4: The Performance Development Discussion Meeting Oct 27, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 2: Preparing for PDDs Oct 28, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Nov 01, 2021
Manage your Team Collaboration Space Nov 02, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 3: Setting Effective Priorities (objectives) Nov 02, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 4: The Performance Development Discussion Meeting Nov 02, 2021
Funded qualifications to consider for your PDD Nov 04, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 1: Introduction to Performance Development Discussions Nov 09, 2021
Interviewing Skills Training (online taught) Nov 11, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Nov 17, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 2: Preparing for PDDs Nov 17, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 3: Setting Effective Priorities (objectives) Nov 18, 2021
Staff Health and Wellbeing Workshop: Achieving a Positive Work Life Balance – Managers’ Workshop Nov 18, 2021
Part 1 - Team Collaboration Space - Channels and conversations Nov 18, 2021
Pre-Retirement Planning Sessions - State Benefits Nov 22, 2021
Pre-Retirement Planning Sessions - Financial Planning Nov 22, 2021
PDD Manager/appraiser Training - Module 4: The Performance Development Discussion Meeting Nov 23, 2021
Pre-Retirement Planning Sessions - Your Pension Schemes and Wellbeing in Retirement Nov 23, 2021
Understanding Stress Workshop Nov 24, 2021
Pre-Retirement Planning Sessions - Estate Planning Nov 24, 2021
An Introduction to Eploy Nov 24, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Nov 29, 2021
Part 2 - Team Collaboration Space - Collaborate on documents Dec 02, 2021
Technicians Network Meetings Dec 08, 2021
Manage your Team Collaboration Space Dec 08, 2021
CLEAPSS - Radiation Protection Supervisor Training Dec 10, 2021
Guided IT Learning Session Dec 16, 2021
Understanding Stress Workshop Dec 17, 2021
More…